How do you fill open shifts?
By Al Davies ยท Updated November 11, 2026
Short answer: Post each open shift in one place with the day, hours and role, ask for replies by a set time, and give it to the first qualified yes. The fix for missed shifts is visibility, so everyone must see the same list.
Why do open shifts sit empty?
A manager on a review site wrote: "Many of my employees are having issues with not seeing available shifts/picking up shifts/swapping shifts." That is one account of one app. Wikipedia lists identifying unassigned shifts as a common scheduling-software feature, so the gap is a known one.
What are the steps?
- Write the shift: day, start and end, role and place.
- Post it where all eligible staff look, not in one chat thread.
- Set a reply deadline, such as noon the day before.
- Take the first qualified yes. Say so to the whole team.
- Mark it filled so nobody replies to a closed shift.
- Keep a short list of people who like extra hours.
Tip: If nobody replies by the deadline, ask your list directly by name.
What does a post look like?
OPEN: Sat 4 to 10 pm, closing cook.
Reply to me by Thu noon.
First yes gets it.
How does this tie to the weekly schedule?
Open shifts are easier when the base schedule is clear. Start from a complete weekly schedule, and make sure staff who skip apps can still see it, as covered in sharing a schedule without an app.
ShiftGarden shows one week for every role on one page, with busy days marked with headcount. Print the week by role with your events and a QR code. Printing also posts it to your team.
FAQ
Who should get an open shift first?
The first qualified yes, unless your team has a fairness rule. State it up front.
Should I post open shifts in a group text?
A text alone is easy to miss. Post it in the schedule place too.
How do I stop double replies?
Mark the shift filled as soon as someone takes it.
What if nobody wants it?
Ask people by name from your extra-hours list.
Sources
Related guides
- How to Make an Employee Schedule: 6 Steps, Sample Week
- How to Share a Work Schedule With Employees Without an App
- How to Switch Employee Scheduling Software Step by Step
- Monthly Work Schedule Template: Free Layout to Copy
Try ShiftGarden to put your week on one page.